Finding a new competitive edge

Clark Butcher was looking for more than a good education when he sent off his college applications. He was looking for a college with โ€œkiller terrain.โ€

Thatโ€™s how Butcher, a 30-year-old Memphis native and the owner of Victory Bicycle Studio on Broad Avenue, ended up at Fort Lewis College, a small liberal arts school in Durango, Colo.

Butcher, a cycling enthusiast since he was a child, began racing professionally after his freshman year. For 42 weekends in the year, he raced and did well. Then he raced for six more months and didnโ€™t do as well.

โ€œI quickly realized I donโ€™t operate well on one thing,โ€ Butcher, who returned to school after racing didnโ€™t pan out, says. โ€œJust training and racing wasnโ€™t healthy for me.โ€

But neither was school, he adds. An entrepreneur whoโ€™d started several companies before college, Butcher knew more about starting a business than some of his teachers, and soon decided to focus on growing his companies.

โ€œI still have that competitive edge,โ€ he says of his time in professional racing.

That competitive edge led Butcher to envision a different kind of bike shop, one that looks more like an Apple Store with an emphasis on quality over quantity.

โ€œIโ€™m a lot younger than all the other bike shop owners out there and I have a very different approach in that I donโ€™t believe in stacking bikes three stories high to the ceiling and yielding the most sellable project per square foot.โ€

In August 2010, Butcher and a partner, who has since been bought out, started Victory on Young Avenue in Midtown. Their building burned down 28 days later, leading to the opening of Victoryโ€™s shop on Broad in August 2011.

Following the traditional wisdom, Butcher should have put his shop โ€“ which sells high-end bikes for as much as $55,000 โ€“ out east, where most of his customers are. But, playing into that โ€œApple Storeโ€ mentality, he wanted to be a destination retailer, and wanted to help make Broad a destination as well.

And so far, the plan seems to be working.

โ€œItโ€™s just grown tremendously over the years,โ€ Butcher says. โ€œItโ€™s gotten to the point where thereโ€™s a couple of motions that need to happen for us to continue growing that Iโ€™m eager to do.โ€

First, Victory will launch online sales of its bikes and its merchandise. Apparel sales are already strong, even without a web store.

If online sales pick up, Butcher says he may buy a warehouse in the area for his distribution operations.

Second, the brand will expand with a second, 2,000-square-foot location in the Broad Avenue area that will focus on a lower price point โ€“ the $300 to $400 range, including for children.

โ€œOneโ€™s going to be more family friendly, more price conscious,โ€ Butcher says. โ€œThe other one will continuing catering to our clientele.โ€

Third, Butcher hopes to start consulting on other bike shop operations.

โ€œEveryone who wants to work at Victory says โ€˜I like bikes,โ€™โ€ Butcher says. โ€œEveryone likes bikes. But you have to like the bike shop business. And thereโ€™s a lot of shop owners that like bikes but donโ€™t like the bike business. So let me come in and take over the not-fun part of the business.โ€

That could result in โ€œVictory-approvedโ€ shops around the country, he says.

Eventually, Butcher hopes to operate Victory Bicycle Studios in other cities, and says he is approached โ€œconstantly.โ€

โ€œOver the past three years, Iโ€™ve been approached about putting ones in Nashville, Chattanooga and North Carolina,โ€ he says. โ€œAnd every one of them, Iโ€™m going โ€˜Not yet, not yet.โ€™ Well, Iโ€™m eager to get to the point where I can actually hit the โ€˜goโ€™ button.โ€